Pancheshwar talks face familiar hurdles ahead of Balen Shah's India visit
Pancheshwar is expected to come up during Prime Minister Balen Shah's India visit from November 22, but officials in Kathmandu say a breakthrough is unlikely amid disputes over cost-sharing and water rights.
Discussions on the long-stalled Pancheshwar Multipurpose Project are expected to return to the bilateral table during Prime Minister Balen Shah's upcoming visit to India, which begins on November 22, though officials in Kathmandu play down the chances of an immediate breakthrough.
The hydro and irrigation project on the Mahakali River is likely to be one of five key issues on the agenda for the talks, My Republica reported, citing government officials. It added that Indian media, citing Uttarakhand Cabinet Minister Satpal Maharaj, had reported that the project would be discussed alongside cross-border trade, infrastructure including a proposed dry port in Mahendranagar, and tourism promotion in Nepal's Terai region. Preparations for the visit are under way in Uttarakhand.
Yet energy and foreign ministry officials told Onlinekhabar that, although both sides are positive about putting Pancheshwar on the agenda, there is no prospect of concrete progress. Three decades after the 1996 Mahakali Treaty, which provides for the project, the two countries have still not agreed on its Detailed Project Report (DPR); the outlet said disagreements over how to value the benefits, how to share the investment and how to divide the downstream benefits have kept the technical teams from settling it.
Unresolved splits on investment and irrigation
Onlinekhabar reported that Nepal and India do not dispute sharing the electricity from the proposed 311-metre-high dam equally, but that they disagree on how to value the irrigation and flood-control benefits, which has sharpened the dispute over who pays what. According to the outlet, Nepal has proposed bearing 30 percent of the cost and India 70 percent, arguing that India would gain most from flood control and irrigation, including water for 240,000 hectares. India has claimed that Nepal should bear 35 percent, and the report says India is ready to bear the other 65 percent. Under the Mahakali Treaty, Onlinekhabar noted, each side is to bear costs in proportion to the benefits it receives.
My Republica gave a different picture of the gap. It reported that the two countries had reportedly narrowed their differences over construction costs, with discussions indicating that Nepal would contribute around 25 to 30 percent of the total investment and India would finance the remainder. The two accounts differ, and the sources do not settle which reflects the current position.
Water allocation downstream is another sticking point. Onlinekhabar said the Indian side insists that the water rights it already exercises through the Lower Sharada Barrage, 163 kilometres downstream of the Sharada Barrage at Banbasa, must not shrink once Pancheshwar is built. Nepal's position, according to the report, is that India mixes water from the Karnali (known in India as the Ghaghara) into that lower barrage and so cannot claim Mahakali water there, that a shared river's water should be divided equally, and that India should pay for any extra it takes.
Political obstacles on both sides
Onlinekhabar quoted a senior government source as saying that India has conveyed that an agreement is possible only if Nepal arrives with broad political consensus, since the project has long divided opinion at home. The same source suggested India may be raising the demand to shift its own difficulty onto Nepal: the dam would submerge large areas in both countries and displace more than 30,000 people in Uttarakhand, where regional parties and environmental campaigners have protested against it, notably in 2010 and 2017 in Dehradun and other towns.
Former energy secretary Chiranjiwi Chataut told Onlinekhabar that enough study and analysis of benefit sharing has been done, and that the political leadership now needs to give a clear roadmap on benefit sharing and investment. Onlinekhabar reported that a team of experts, led on Nepal's side by the secretary of the Water and Energy Commission Secretariat and on India's by the Central Water Commission, has met four or five times without reaching a conclusion.
For the current 2083/84 fiscal year, Onlinekhabar reported, the government has allocated Rs 1.20 crore for the Pancheshwar Development Authority and DPR-related work, but it noted that a budget allocation alone will not move the project forward while there is no agreement on investment, benefit sharing and water use.