Supreme Court rejects Marwadi Sewa Samiti's tenancy claim on Pashupati dharmashala
The Supreme Court has refused Marwadi Sewa Samiti leave to review its tenancy case over the Pashupati Gaushala Dharmashala, clearing the way for the Pashupati Area Development Trust to reclaim the guthi land.
The Supreme Court has refused Marwadi Sewa Samiti permission to have its tenancy case over the Pashupati Gaushala Dharmashala heard again, clearing the way for the Pashupati Area Development Trust to reclaim the building and the guthi land it stands on.
A division bench of Justices Tek Prasad Dhungana and Shanti Singh Thapa rejected the committee's petition for a review of the Patan High Court's verdict, according to Khabarhub and Nepal Live. Nepal Live and Aarthik News report that the order found no ground for a review under Section 12(1) of the Administration of Justice Act, 2073. The Patan High Court's ruling of Monday 4 May 2026, which had upheld a Kathmandu District Court decision of Wednesday 2 October 2024, therefore stands.
Khabarhub reported that the Supreme Court issued the order on Tuesday 29 September 2026, and that the Trust and the bodies concerned were told late because of the Dashain, Tihar and Chhath holidays. None of the four reports carried a response from the committee.
Courts reject tenancy rights over guthi land
The dispute concerns two plots registered under the Shree Pashupati Amalkot Kachahari guthi in the former Pashupati Ward 2: plot 83, measuring four ropani, 15 aana and two daam, and plot 85, measuring four ropani and 10 aana. Lokaantar and Aarthik News reported that, with the Supreme Court's refusal, the finding that the committee has no tenancy right over either plot stands.
Nepal Live reported that the Kathmandu District Court found the committee had not produced authentic proof of tenancy, and that photocopies of tenancy registration certificates could not establish the right. According to Khabarhub, the court relied chiefly on an agreement of Jeth 12, 2060 BS (2003), in which the committee itself accepted the Amalkot Kachahari's full ownership of the dharmashala's buildings, and held that this barred it from later claiming tenant rights.
The Trust cancelled that agreement on Wednesday 2 August 2023. Khabarhub reported that the agreement set no time limit and that its conditions, including an annual payment of Rs 51,000, had not been revised as earlier directions from the Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority, the Special Court and the Supreme Court required; the court held the cancellation lawful. Nepal Live added that the Special Court's ruling of Jeth 31, 2067 BS (2010) and the Supreme Court's of Asar 27, 2068 BS (2011) had said such terms could be amended.
Former Trust official says it should run as a non-profit
Dr Milan Kumar Thapa, a former member secretary of the Trust, said the ruling ends a legal struggle of about a decade and returns the property to the Trust. He said the dharmashala should now be run as a non-profit service for religious and social purposes, in coordination with government bodies, for devotees visiting the Pashupatinath temple, under a Trust board decision of Asoj 20, 2081 (Sunday 6 October 2024) and an agreement between the Trust and Kathmandu Metropolitan City. He called on the government to clear the building without delay. Nepal Live reported that Thapa was the Trust's member secretary when the committee took its case to the Patan High Court, and was among the 12 respondents it named.
Advocate Krishna Murari Pudasaini said that, with courts at all three levels having ruled, the government faces no legal obstacle to carrying out the judgment and clearing the dharmashala.
Thapa also gave the property's history. He said a slip of Jeth 5, 1999 BS (1942) let a man grow grass on the land to feed the bulls left at the temple, and that Trust records show no tenant on the two plots, which together measure about nine ropani and nine aana. The records, he said, show the committee was given the dharmashala only to run, in 2060 BS (2003).